Best Pick and Mix Candy Online: Where to Build Your Own Candy Bag

What Is Pick and Mix Candy?

Pick and mix candy — called lösgodis in Swedish — is the tradition of choosing individual candies piece by piece to build your own custom bag. Instead of being locked into whatever a prepackaged bag contains, you select exactly what you want: a handful of BUBS Sour Skulls, a few pieces of salt licorice, some chocolate-covered marshmallows, and whatever else catches your eye.

In Sweden, this isn't a novelty — it's how most candy is bought. Every grocery store has an entire wall of candy bins (the lösgodis wall), and millions of Swedes fill their bags every Saturday as part of the lördagsgodis tradition. Thanks to TikTok and growing interest in Swedish candy, this experience is now available online for Americans who want to try it themselves.

The best pick and mix candy online stores let you replicate that Swedish candy wall from your couch. But quality, selection, and pricing vary wildly between retailers. We tested and ranked the major options.

How We Ranked the Best Pick and Mix Stores

We evaluated each store based on five criteria:

• Selection breadth: How many individual candies can you pick from? A true lösgodis experience needs 50+ varieties minimum.
• Authenticity: Are these real Swedish imports or American-made "Swedish style" candy? We verified brand origins.
• Price per piece/weight: Pick and mix pricing is tricky — some stores charge per piece, others by weight, others sell fixed-size bags. We normalized for comparison.
• Shipping speed and cost: Candy can melt, and waiting three weeks kills the excitement. We prioritized fast, reasonable shipping.
• Freshness guarantee: Swedish candy uses fewer preservatives than American candy, so freshness matters more.

Best Online Pick and Mix Candy Stores (2026 Rankings)

1. BonBon NYC — Best Overall Pick and Mix

Selection: ★★★★★ | Price: ★★★☆☆ | Authenticity: ★★★★★ | Shipping: ★★★★☆

BonBon started as a physical candy store in New York City and became the epicenter of America's Swedish candy obsession. Their online pick-and-mix lets you choose from dozens of authentic imports — BUBS sour skulls, Malaco licorice, Cloetta chocolates, and more. Everything is sourced directly from Swedish distributors.

Why they're #1: The selection is unmatched. They carry products you won't find anywhere else in the US, including seasonal Swedish candies and limited-edition BUBS flavors. Their physical store in NYC means they turn over inventory fast, so freshness is rarely an issue.

Watch out for: Pricing is on the higher end, especially for small orders. Their pick-and-mix bags start around $15-20 for a basic selection, and shipping from NYC isn't cheap if you're on the West Coast. Best value comes from larger orders ($50+) where the per-candy cost drops significantly.

2. Sockerbit — Best Premium Experience

Selection: ★★★★☆ | Price: ★★☆☆☆ | Authenticity: ★★★★★ | Shipping: ★★★★☆

Sockerbit (Swedish for "sugar cube") operates physical stores in Los Angeles and New York, plus a polished online shop. Their pick-and-mix experience is curated — they don't try to carry everything, but what they do carry is carefully selected and beautifully presented.

Why they stand out: Sockerbit is the best option if you're buying candy as a gift or for a special occasion. Their packaging is premium, their branding is clean, and the overall experience feels elevated. They also carry a solid selection of licorice and salmiak for more adventurous buyers.

Watch out for: This is the most expensive option. You're paying for the brand experience, and per-candy pricing reflects that. If you just want to try Swedish candy without the premium markup, other stores offer better value.

3. Mums Swedish Candy — Best for Custom Mixes

Selection: ★★★★☆ | Price: ★★★★☆ | Authenticity: ★★★★★ | Shipping: ★★★★★

Mums is a dedicated Swedish candy retailer with an intuitive online pick-and-mix system. You build your bag by selecting from their catalog of authentic Swedish imports, and they ship from within the US for fast delivery. Their mix-and-match pricing rewards bigger orders.

Why they stand out: Mums hits the sweet spot between selection, price, and convenience. Their US-based shipping means 2-5 day delivery for most addresses, and they regularly run promotions. The website makes it easy to filter by type (sour, sweet, licorice, chocolate) and build a balanced bag.

Watch out for: The selection is slightly smaller than BonBon's, particularly for niche licorice varieties. But for most buyers — especially first-timers — the core selection covers everything you need.

4. Swedish Candy Store — Best Value Pick and Mix

Selection: ★★★★☆ | Price: ★★★★★ | Authenticity: ★★★★☆ | Shipping: ★★★★☆

Colorado-based Swedish Candy Store has been importing since 2015 and consistently offers the most competitive pricing for pick-and-mix. They sell both individual products and build-your-own bundles at prices that undercut most competitors.

Why they stand out: If you're watching your budget but want real Swedish candy, this is the go-to. Shipping from Colorado means reasonable rates for most of the US, and their per-candy prices are typically 15-25% lower than BonBon or Sockerbit.

Watch out for: The website design is functional rather than fancy. Selection rotates based on what's available from their importers, so specific products may come and go.

5. Swedish Candy Land — Best for Bulk Orders

Selection: ★★★★☆ | Price: ★★★★★ | Authenticity: ★★★★☆ | Shipping: ★★★★☆

Swedish Candy Land frequently has the lowest per-unit pricing, especially for larger orders. They ship within 24 hours of ordering, which means your candy arrives while the excitement is still fresh.

Why they stand out: Bulk pricing is their strength. If you're hosting a Swedish candy tasting party or stocking up for regular lördagsgodis, the savings add up quickly. Orders of 1kg+ are where you'll see the biggest price advantage.

Watch out for: Minimum order thresholds may apply for free shipping. Read the fine print before placing small orders.

6. Nordic Cravings — Best for International Shipping

Selection: ★★★☆☆ | Price: ★★★★☆ | Authenticity: ★★★★☆ | Shipping: ★★★★★

Nordic Cravings offers free worldwide shipping on orders over $75, making them the best option if you're ordering from outside the continental US. They carry BUBS, Malaco, and other core Swedish brands.

Why they stand out: The free international shipping threshold is the lowest we've found. If you're in Canada, the UK, or Australia and want Swedish candy, this is your best bet for avoiding painful shipping fees.

7. Nantasket Sweets by Swedes — Best for Health-Conscious Buyers

Selection: ★★★★☆ | Price: ★★★☆☆ | Authenticity: ★★★★★ | Shipping: ★★★★☆

Based in Massachusetts, Nantasket Sweets runs both a physical store and online shop with a strong emphasis on natural, gluten-free, and gelatin-free options. If you or your family have dietary restrictions, their filtered selection saves time.

Why they stand out: They clearly label vegan, gluten-free, and naturally colored products. This makes building a dietary-restriction-friendly pick-and-mix bag much easier than sorting through a general catalog. See our vegan Swedish candy guide for more on allergen-safe options.

Pick and Mix Price Comparison

Pricing varies significantly between stores, and it's not always easy to compare because stores use different units (per piece, per weight, per bag). Here's an approximate guide based on our testing:

Store	Approx. Cost per 500g	Free Shipping Threshold	Ships From
BonBon NYC	$18-25	~$50	New York
Sockerbit	$22-30	~$50	New York / LA
Mums Swedish Candy	$15-22	Varies	US-based
Swedish Candy Store	$13-18	~$50	Colorado
Swedish Candy Land	$12-17	~$60	US-based
Nordic Cravings	$16-22	$75 (worldwide)	Varies

Prices are approximate and fluctuate. Always check current pricing before ordering.

How to Build the Perfect Pick and Mix Bag

Building a great pick-and-mix bag is an art. The key is variety — you want contrasting flavors and textures so every handful is different. Here's a formula that works:

The Balanced Bag Formula

• 2-3 sour candies (30% of bag): Start with BUBS Sour Skulls — they're the crowd favorite for a reason. Add BUBS Watermelon for a fruitier sour, and S-Märke Surt Skum if you want intense, fizzy sourness.
• 1-2 sweet/fruity candies (20%): Ahlgrens Bilar for marshmallow sweetness, or BUBS Banana Ovals for creamy fruit flavor.
• 1-2 chocolate pieces (20%): Daim for crunchy toffee, Plopp for smooth chocolate-toffee, or Kexchoklad for a light wafer bar.
• 1 licorice option (15%): Skipper's Pipes for beginners, Gott & Blandat for a mixed experience, or Djungelvrål if you're feeling brave.
• 1 wild card (15%): Something you've never tried. This is the whole point of pick and mix — exploration. Kryptoniter (layered sour-salmiak balls) is a great wild card.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• All sour, all the time: Your taste buds will fatigue quickly. Mix in sweet and chocolate to reset your palate.
• Ignoring licorice entirely: Even if you think you don't like licorice, Swedish licorice is genuinely different from the American stuff. Try at least one mild option.
• Ordering too little: 200g feels generous in the store but disappears fast at home. 500g is a more realistic single-person order for a week's worth of Saturday candy.
• Skipping the classics: Don't fill your bag entirely with TikTok-famous BUBS. Brands like Malaco and Cloetta are where the cultural depth lives.

Pick and Mix vs. Pre-Made Candy Bags

Many Swedish candy stores also sell pre-made bags and variety packs. Here's when each makes sense:

Choose pick and mix when:

• You know what you like and want to control the ratio
• You have dietary restrictions and need to select specific products
• You're hosting a tasting and want maximum variety
• You want to try specific individual candies before committing to a full bag

Choose pre-made bags when:

• You're a total beginner and want a curated introduction (see our beginner's guide)
• You're buying a gift and want it to look polished
• You want the convenience of one click, no decisions
• The per-unit pricing on a bundle is significantly better than pick-and-mix

Shipping Tips for Pick and Mix Candy Orders

Swedish candy is more delicate than most American candy because it uses natural ingredients and fewer preservatives. Here's how to protect your order:

Temperature

Gummies and chocolate can melt in transit during summer months (May through September in most of the US). Order early in the week so your package isn't sitting in a hot warehouse over the weekend. Many stores offer insulated packaging for an extra $3-5 — worth it in summer.

Freshness

Swedish candy has a shorter shelf life than American candy — typically 6-12 months from production. Check best-by dates when your order arrives. Most reputable stores rotate stock regularly, but marketplace sellers (eBay, Amazon third-party) may have older inventory.

Storage

Once opened, store gummies and licorice in an airtight container at room temperature. Chocolate should stay below 70°F. Properly stored, most Swedish candy stays fresh for 2-4 weeks after opening — though it rarely lasts that long.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best pick and mix candy store online?

BonBon NYC has the widest selection of authentic Swedish pick-and-mix candy online. For better value, Swedish Candy Store and Swedish Candy Land offer lower per-candy pricing. For the best all-around balance of selection, price, and shipping speed, Mums Swedish Candy is our top recommendation for most buyers.

How much does pick and mix candy cost?

Expect to spend $12-30 per 500g depending on the store and what you choose. Premium items like chocolate and specialty licorice cost more per weight than standard gummies. Stores that sell by weight tend to offer better value than those selling by piece. Budget $20-25 for a generous first order that covers a good variety of candies.

Is Swedish pick and mix candy different from British pick and mix?

Yes. Swedish lösgodis emphasizes sour gummies, salmiak licorice, and naturally colored candies. British pick and mix leans toward boiled sweets, fizzy cola bottles, and marshmallows. The flavor profiles are quite different, with Swedish candy offering more intense sour and salty-licorice options. See our Swedish vs British pick and mix comparison for a detailed breakdown.

Can I get pick and mix candy on Amazon?

Amazon has some Swedish candy, but the pick-and-mix experience is limited. You're mostly buying pre-packaged bags from third-party sellers at marked-up prices. For a real pick-and-mix experience where you choose individual candies, you'll need to order from a dedicated Swedish candy store. Check our Amazon Swedish candy guide for what's worth buying there and what to skip.

Do pick and mix stores ship internationally?

Most US-based stores ship domestically. Nordic Cravings offers free worldwide shipping on orders over $75, making them the best option for international orders. Some stores like Sockerbit and BonBon also ship internationally, but fees can be steep. If you're outside the US, check each store's shipping policy before ordering.

How long does Swedish pick and mix candy last?

Sealed bags typically stay fresh for 6-12 months (check best-by dates). Once opened, gummies and licorice are best consumed within 2-4 weeks. Chocolate stays good longer if stored below 70°F. Swedish candy uses fewer preservatives than American candy, so freshness matters more — don't stockpile months in advance.